I bought both of these bags because they’re listed as the same size, but as you can see in the photo, the vegan leather version is noticeably larger and much more spacious.
When I transferred all my baby essentials from the vegan leather bag into the black wide top, the black one looked bulky and cramped with barely any room left. Meanwhile, the vegan leather bag still had space to spare — much easier to organize and pack without feeling stuffed.
Another big difference is the backpack straps. The vegan leather straps are thicker, more padded, and much more comfortable on the shoulders compared to the black wide top, which feels a bit cheaper in quality.
I’m not saying the black one is terrible, but the size listing is very misleading. If you’re deciding between the two and want more space and comfort, I’d definitely recommend the vegan leather version. I’ll be keeping that one and returning the black.